The technology that’s replacing the green screen

  Ganger 3,749,992

Vox

Måned siden

The green screen is a Hollywood staple. Should it be?
It’s easy to complain about overreliance on special effects, but for projects that require impossible-to-film environments or have incredibly expensive shots, how do you get the flexibility of green screens without the drawbacks?
Charmaine Chan has worked on one of the possible answers. Vox's Phil Edwards spoke to her about her career and how it's at the forefront of a big technological shift. As a compositor for venerable effects house Industrial Light and Magic (ILM), she’s worked on films like The Last Jedi, assembling various digital elements into a beautiful, seamless image. Her job changed on The Mandalorian, one of the first shows to use ILM’s upgrade for the green screen: LED panels that used video game engine technology to place a realistic-looking world behind the actors.
It was a huge improvement, because green screens actually have a lot of drawbacks. Removing the green screen is never as quick as visual effects artists would hope. It also casts green light upon the set and actors. Even substitutes for a green screen, like projecting an image onto a screen behind the actor, fail to dynamically respond to camera movements the way they would in the real world.
ILM’s solution fixes a lot of those problems, and it also led to creative breakthroughs in which the old Hollywood order of a TV show or movie, in which VFX came last, was suddenly reversed. Now, artists like Charmaine are alongside actors, set designers, and other crew members during filming. That collaboration means that this technology doesn’t just eliminate a screen - it eliminates a creative barrier.
Watch the above video to see how it happens.
Subscribe to our channel! goo.gl/0bsAjO
Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com.
Watch our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
Follow Vox on Facebook: goo.gl/U2g06o
Or Twitter: goo.gl/XFrZ5H

Kommentarer
Vox
Vox 2 dager siden
We just launched our official online store! Get your Vox tees, hoodies, hats - and exclusive Vox Atlas, Earworm, and Missing Chapter stickers - all in one place at www.vox.com/shop
dude no
dude no Dag siden
@Preston Ak i made it 8 you’re welcome :)
Preston Ak
Preston Ak Dag siden
7 likes, that’s not normal it should be at 8
TheRubberStudiosASMR
TheRubberStudiosASMR Time siden
Brilliant video. I find this stuff fascinating
Cruz Froehlich
Cruz Froehlich Time siden
It's also great for the actors, because instead of having to imagine for instance, "a big scary explosion in a mile's radius" they can actually see it, which makes their acting more convincing.
EdoArt
EdoArt 7 timer siden
interesting but I have no idea how much cost such tech could have and how long will take to be available for the rest of us, in the other hand 3D software is becoming more and more powerful day by day and can have less cost just develop a movie with 3d models without using actors at all, I believe is probably the way things are going right now because 3d engines right now have hyper-realistic HD resolution I am not sure but in the case of the Mandolarian the cost could be decrease is they use just 3D models and the 3D software will deal with the lighting colors reflections etc
Jiro
Jiro 10 timer siden
New way not a replacement
Bryce Wentzel
Bryce Wentzel 11 timer siden
this is the coolest thing I have seen, that would be EPIC to be there, just imagine playing around with it, t would be so fun
Eye of Sauron
Eye of Sauron 17 timer siden
*If you have that led panels you can still use green screen technology by making led screens green. 2in1 tech.*
hackLAB
hackLAB 18 timer siden
I am making a $10 Dollar sci-fi movie using a $30 green screen
hackLAB
hackLAB 18 timer siden
Affordable for home use?
the great finn
the great finn 21 time siden
this is soooo goood!!, but the way she speaks kinda irritates me idk whyyy
Zeksteve
Zeksteve 23 timer siden
A holodeck
SSS SSS
SSS SSS 23 timer siden
The music could be a bit less dramatic man
More Spencer
More Spencer Dag siden
i like how shes does vfx for a living but her camera outputs at 15fps
Stratus Above
Stratus Above Dag siden
The world that the children made.
Edmond O'Brien
Edmond O'Brien Dag siden
Don't give all NASA's Secrets away
Cyrus Esfahani
Cyrus Esfahani Dag siden
Man ILM never stops innovating, well done
Nikolaos Skordilis
Nikolaos Skordilis Dag siden
Do LED panels of a high enough resolution already exist that when viewing the show on a large (70+") 4K screen their pixels will not be discerned? Or do the show creators use LED panels of a more reasonable pixel density but take care not to get the camera too close to them - and perhaps if/when they do they use a softening filter to smooth out the pixels? The idea sounds great, but I suppose it can only work if the combined pixel density of the LED panels & shooting distance is greater than the combined pixel density of the largest TV sets & the viewing distance of the audience. Otherwise softening/blurring filters would need to be used, but those decrease clarity and sharpness. If 4K LED panels of
rumahpotret.photography
rumahpotret.photography Dag siden
later, it will be like a projection dome in startrek.
Micah
Micah Dag siden
Must be trippy when the camera moves...
Max Films
Max Films Dag siden
Ok. Fantastic. Amateur filmmaking is dead. That's all folks!
FeDrO Ufficiale
FeDrO Ufficiale Dag siden
I mean it's not a new technology but it was done in other ways
Lauren Rebec
Lauren Rebec Dag siden
First off when you dropped the light on baby yoda I almost lost it with laughter!! haaha Amazing video I am completely beyond blowwwww away!! Inspired isn't even the word! I am so ready to dive more into this new coming technology. Its really just projection upgraded! Open to chat with anyone else who cant help but to talk about it! Sorry I have no friends that are interested in this stuff haha!
THE EVERYTHING
THE EVERYTHING Dag siden
much expensive
Niall Moran
Niall Moran Dag siden
The Truman Show
Reprogramming Mind
Reprogramming Mind Dag siden
Five to ten minutes!
Diosa Mamii
Diosa Mamii Dag siden
All this for a tiny movie
Sid Sid
Sid Sid Dag siden
Guys this is a too complex for a home or small studio, granted that the production quality is going to be better, a skillful vfx magician will know how to achieve similar results, & cost is always problem.
Kauri Channel
Kauri Channel 2 dager siden
if only paints are made of micro led that changes color
Spencer Young
Spencer Young 2 dager siden
Can't wait to see this tech come to consumers so NakeyJakey can have memes all around him on his yoga ball.
Jessie Marshall Jr
Jessie Marshall Jr 2 dager siden
Didn’t Ray Bradbury make a novel about something similar to this? Lol
Haris Bennington
Haris Bennington 2 dager siden
Just do it in iMovie
Diving Up
Diving Up 2 dager siden
beautiful minecraft?
JJ K
JJ K 2 dager siden
4:30 NO!!!!!! lol nice acting
Zaktron
Zaktron 2 dager siden
This makes me want to check the walls of my room, just to make sure they're not LED panels.
Truth Seeker
Truth Seeker 2 dager siden
Digital enlightenment
Paul Freedman
Paul Freedman 2 dager siden
Stunningly brilliant.
Jpaul Getty productions
Jpaul Getty productions 2 dager siden
I have zero respect for those who contributed to Artemis Foul
Control Televisión
Control Televisión 2 dager siden
So this was just an ad for The Mandalorian, wasn't it?
Snooks
Snooks 2 dager siden
though with this all VFX has to be planned and implemented ahead of time and you can't mess up anything or the whole thing needs to be reshot. probably works better for TV than movies
the demons
the demons 2 dager siden
imagine gaming on this screen
Moses Ramirez
Moses Ramirez 2 dager siden
This is really just a digital equivalent to the matte paintings used in the original Star Wars, which would help (partly) explain how the feel of The Mandalorian is so close to its source material.
Daniel Green
Daniel Green 3 dager siden
I don’t like how industrial light and Magic do films that aren’t under the Disney umbrella like Aqua-man. Stop helping the competition!
binbows225
binbows225 2 dager siden
what are you even saying
OldGamerMusic
OldGamerMusic 3 dager siden
The technology that NO ONE CAN AFFORD
Zeksteve
Zeksteve 23 timer siden
Cheaper than flying 3 dozen people halfway across the world
Evaldas Klupsas
Evaldas Klupsas 3 dager siden
🔥🔥very interesting🔥🔥
Maurizio Abile
Maurizio Abile 3 dager siden
And she explained everything though a Green Screen
Teflon Smile
Teflon Smile 3 dager siden
Frame by frame!
Teflon Smile
Teflon Smile 3 dager siden
They have a room like this inside EXXONMOBIL headquarters 🔎🔥 one of 2 rooms....cool idea! Its very very unreal
Insane Cuckooman
Insane Cuckooman 3 dager siden
i hate the way she talks
Farhang Abdinzade
Farhang Abdinzade 3 dager siden
her sound is soooo anoyying omg i cant contineo
Oliver McFadden
Oliver McFadden 3 dager siden
this is an awesome creative solution! and now we don’t have to listen to mfers complain about how modern filmmaking killed film
Amelia Pinky
Amelia Pinky 3 dager siden
With the help of vortexhackers. com. I was able to recover my lost btc which was stolen by some binary traders . .. . .
impooser
impooser 3 dager siden
8:22 of Californian vocal frying
Jordan Osburn
Jordan Osburn 3 dager siden
I’ve met Charmaine once presenting at my college campus, it was really amazing to see how much change these led panels would introduce to the visual effects world!
Julie Burke
Julie Burke 3 dager siden
I'm very surprised there is no mention of Epics Unreal Engine which is the real tech behind this Virtual Production process. Its also sad that real locations won't be necessary for future film making, photogrammetry of the world will replace the real thing.
Paul Cwick
Paul Cwick 4 dager siden
"It’s easy to complain about overreliance on special effects" With good reason. Too many contemporary movies appear to be 99.99% special effects, and maybe 0.01% intelligent thought put into plot, story-structure or character-development.
Ione Velasquez
Ione Velasquez 4 dager siden
WOW
sebatian
sebatian 4 dager siden
I hate asians.
wdavem
wdavem 4 dager siden
This video is dripping with public relations. The technology is good. Like an improved rear projection. But the video is leaking public relations out of it's huh.
Umair Asghar
Umair Asghar 4 dager siden
have you ever tried the change background feature in skype or zoom?
GoofyTall
GoofyTall 4 dager siden
The Volume? Don't you mean The Holodeck?
DoctorX17
DoctorX17 4 dager siden
I have purple screen
fatarsemonkey
fatarsemonkey 4 dager siden
So a modern version of what Stanley Kubrick did.
clay
clay 2 dager siden
@fatarsemonkey Yeah you're right.
fatarsemonkey
fatarsemonkey 2 dager siden
@clay Well, I was just implying it's not exactly ground breaking.
clay
clay 2 dager siden
Yeah but much easier than what Stanley Kubrick did.
Mioumi
Mioumi 4 dager siden
How does one interact with an object that goes from the volume to the real scene without a cut?
durr clips
durr clips 4 dager siden
has it been used for anythin but static empty landscapes? Yeah ok standing in a desert is cool but this seems limited. You cant shoot anything where you need to move more than 15 feet
rowelle
rowelle 4 dager siden
I understand this new technology is more efficient, but is it cost effective? Looks like it costs more to do this than to do green screen.
Alexandre Bugado
Alexandre Bugado 4 dager siden
so it is a real time -ray tr- green screen
Phil Christophers
Phil Christophers 4 dager siden
yeah I was okay till you started promoting 5G which is not good for humans come back to the human race
Luke Evans
Luke Evans 4 dager siden
Same technology used in 'Oblivion' 7 years ago
Damon Zap
Damon Zap 4 dager siden
my thoughts exactly. I was hoping someone wrote this in the comments selection. 🖖
Alan Smith
Alan Smith 4 dager siden
my question would be about the floor... how is that done to fit into the ocean?
ShortMovie Editor
ShortMovie Editor 4 dager siden
it would cost less to just like go to the actual spot and record
Linus Wärn
Linus Wärn 4 dager siden
Why haven't we invented high resolution conference calls yet?
Linus Wärn
Linus Wärn 3 dager siden
@GG-Private I have fiber broadband. I was referring to the woman's low res image.
GG-Private
GG-Private 3 dager siden
Your internet or LTE might not support affordable high res calls yet so no use using high res conference cams.
theacp127
theacp127 4 dager siden
It's amazing that the studio who basically revolutionized key removal with the original Star Wars film is still innovating years later to create more amazing Star Wars content.
April Mintac Pineda
April Mintac Pineda 4 dager siden
So the "new" tech that will replace green screen editing because it's a better solution, is basically a tech of the past that they ditched for green screen? That's the equivalent of choosing the wrong guy and coming back crying 😂😂
Fun Film
Fun Film 4 dager siden
Is there a way to do this for us lower budget filmmakers, say like for only 1-2 million?
sK3LeTvM
sK3LeTvM 4 dager siden
Nothing new. This technique has allready been used by Stanley Kubrick for filming A Space Odyssey. Though it was (rear) film projection instead of LED screens at that time.
Radu Caseti
Radu Caseti 5 dager siden
But they still eat pangolins...🤷🏿‍♂️
Casey Chisholm
Casey Chisholm 5 dager siden
Holodeck
Her BaSS
Her BaSS 5 dager siden
och X-Men Fight room
Alisa Komendova
Alisa Komendova 5 dager siden
When she talked about removing the uneven green screen frame by frame, I felt physically ill. They are the real heroes
Daniel Grove Photo
Daniel Grove Photo 5 dager siden
How do real camera movements translate or get measured and put in to the system so that the 3d renders correspond to the camera angle changes?
Green Moxy
Green Moxy 5 dager siden
Can you play call of duty on the LED screen?
Mr. Ant
Mr. Ant 5 dager siden
Before I knew about this I thought the mandalorian was filmed at real places around the world
Karolis Jurevicius
Karolis Jurevicius 5 dager siden
VFX is the least appreciated team in filmmaking when it comes to general audiences and mainstream films.
JBulsara A
JBulsara A 5 dager siden
However the screen is...now they need to learn how to act right in front of a camera.
Sourish W.
Sourish W. 5 dager siden
I got a Verizon ad as soon as the main video ended, then got another vox sponsor speech lol
MrSaemichlaus
MrSaemichlaus 5 dager siden
Dis is da we.
hypnotic1979
hypnotic1979 5 dager siden
BOOOOOO 5G !!! It doesn´t only make technology different IT ALSO RUINS LIFE ON EARTH, so PLEASE BANN 5G EVERYWHERE... everywhere where you love people and nature to survive healthier...
katasiapa
katasiapa 5 dager siden
Me: How much the technology price compare to green screen? Her: Your house.
Zeksteve
Zeksteve 23 timer siden
How much do think a set costs to build or flying to cast and crew to location
rowelle
rowelle 4 dager siden
My exact question.
Erik Hendrych
Erik Hendrych 5 dager siden
Those panels must ve really special. Seen those people who film their computer screen instead of using screen capture software? It looks horrible!
~ImaginedByMe~
~ImaginedByMe~ 6 dager siden
i did not expect anything different than a jebait from vox tbh
Michaelangelo A Barreto
Michaelangelo A Barreto 6 dager siden
This same screen technology is used in The Bourne Stuntacular live show at Universal Studios Florida. So if you want to see this live, check out that show. It is breath taking.
Animatroix
Animatroix 6 dager siden
what if the whole world is just a green screen?
wedoebe
wedoebe 6 dager siden
This was plain and simply awesome!!🤓
p c
p c 6 dager siden
It would not be too surprising if a future iteration of 'The Volume' were to be more like a half sphere and much larger.
kngston20
kngston20 6 dager siden
Soaring over California needs to upgrade to this technology. Those screens are getting dated.
IsThisLeftUnity?
IsThisLeftUnity? 6 dager siden
I kinda assumed that most of the Mandalorian was filmed on location with the backgrounds edited in later. Compared to the creature and vehicle CG it looked almost flawless.
Billy Crutchfield
Billy Crutchfield 6 dager siden
COOL !
Matthew Pennington
Matthew Pennington 6 dager siden
This is incredible development on the part of the lead technologist, she is amazing, but why scrimp on a glitchy zoom call quality interview for this piece? I'd implore you to re-shoot this in her developed tech! Amazing work highlighting such talent, not meant as a criticism. Big love.
isabella live 2.0
isabella live 2.0 6 dager siden
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Wow 2.5 seconds really!!! I mean Ah!!!!!!!!!!!5G!!!
Mick Murray
Mick Murray 6 dager siden
How can we change the way voices sound?
The Fastest Gaming PC is now AMD!
17:09
Linus Tech Tips
Ganger 3,3 mill
Spårtsklubben #126: Bot og TV-tabbe
19:03
Spårtsklubben VGTV
Ganger 16 k
4044 M&M's Challenge (17,690 Calories)
9:40
World's Lightest Solid!
12:02
Veritasium
Ganger 24 mill
The Insane Biology of: The Octopus
21:27
Real Science
Ganger 2,1 mill
The Infinite Pattern That Never Repeats
21:12
The Fastest Gaming PC is now AMD!
17:09
Linus Tech Tips
Ganger 3,3 mill
Spårtsklubben #126: Bot og TV-tabbe
19:03
Spårtsklubben VGTV
Ganger 16 k
4044 M&M's Challenge (17,690 Calories)
9:40
Levelling up in a boss fight - Level Up
1:51
Viva La Dirt League
Ganger 574 k
Sen Çal Kapımı 20. Bölüm 2. Fragmanı
0:45
Sen Çal Kapımı
Ganger 2,3 mill
Film Theory: The Lorax Movie LIED To You!
17:32
The Film Theorists
Ganger 3,1 mill